Monday, June 11, 2007

Mera Bharat Mahan!!

During the last few weeks in India, I’ve been through such interesting incidents at 2 different Government Offices that I sadly feel that India has to come a long way - not in technical or economic fronts but in the attitude and behavior of the people – to try to become, as perceived by Dr. A.P.J. Abdul Kalam, a Developed Nation by 2020.

Scenario 1: During coming back from Singapore in early May this year I forgot to check out my room and return my transponder (an electronic equipment used to un/lock doors) at my Hostel Office. I called the Hostel Management people about the issue and they asked me to send the transponder to them by mail once I get back to my city. For the same, when I went to my nearest Post Office to Speed Post my transponder to Singapore, the person at the counter told me that since I’m sending an electronic item, I need to get it passed through the customs for which I was supposed to go to the Head Post Office of Agra City. It made to me complete sense to not allow “anyone” send “anything” by post.

At the Head Post Office, on being asked about Speed Post, the person at the Counter 1 referred me to Counter 4. All 6 counters in the office were next to each other. The guy at Counter 4 asked me to get the stuff checked by the Custom Officer. On being asked about his whereabouts, he said Andar baithe hain! and waved his hand towards his left – towards the main office and also towards Counter 1. I went inside the office through the other side and after passing through I-don’t-how-many rooms where everyone said Custom? Us room mein! always referring to the next room, I finally found out that the Custom Officer sits right behind the guy at Counter 1!

The Custom Officer – sounds like a serious person who keeps a strict eye on every article that comes under his nose. But the scene at this office: A 30-something normal looking guy sits behind a table – a table full of NOTHING. He absolutely had nothing on his table save a closed register and a plastic cup of tea.

Me: Sir, Mujhe ye saamaan Singapore bhejna hai. It’s a transponder. (He makes a questioning face.) Mere room ki key hai.
Officer: Key ka kya hai? Woh log doosri banwa lenge. :P
Me: This is an Electronic key. Agar nahi bheji to mera $40 charge lag jaayega. Aap check kar lijiye.
Officer: To bhej dijiye, problem kya hai?
Me: Woh keh rahe hain aap check karenge (pointing at Counter 4)
Officer: Arey aap waha pahucho to sahi.

I go to Counter 4 and ask the person to look towards the Custom Officer.

Custom Officer: Ye jo bhej rahe hain, bhej do. Who log Dilli mein check kar lenge. Yahaan par check karne ki koi zaroorat nahi hai!

I was like, What the hell? This person would have been appointed here to lessen the burden of the Officers at Delhi. And he is sitting ideally in this busy office doing absolutely nothing – so much so – he tends to avoid every work that comes his way. I thought of the various facilities and privileges people are offered while (and after) working in a Government Office and about the amount of work they (don't) do. The cut-throat competition to get into a Government Office in India suddenly seemed very rational to me.


Scenario 2: I entered the Hajrat Nizamuddin Railway Station in Delhi. It was 5pm and I had to buy a ticket to Agra for a 6 o'clock train. There were 5 ticket counters out of which, only 4 were operational. (Note that the ticket counter schedule confirms that all 5 counters should be operational after 2.30 till atleast 7 in the evening.) Luckily, there weren't any long queues at any of the counters and I decided to stand at counter 3 in spite of a shorter queue at counter 4 (coz there weren't many people at 3 also).

The queue moved fast and within 10 mins, I was the second person to be served. But as soon as the 1st person asked for a ticket, the counter manager kept a Khidki Bandh (Window Closed) sign in front of him - without any prior notification of his intentions or whatsoever. On being asked till when will the counter be closed, he gave no reply as if his duty ends wherever and whenever he wishes to and he is not answerable to any of the customer's queries. Easily came to my mind, a comparison to a private company, where the person-in-charge is commited to fulfil his customer's needs and sees that the customer doesn't feel offended in any manner.

By this time, the other queues had grown longer. Having no choice, I moved to the queue at counter 1 but after standing there for atleast 5 mins (and realizing that it hasn't moved an inch forward :P) I looked up towards the window. The counter incharge was either counting money or something but wasn't taking any orders from the customer standing at the counter. The guy in front of me told that it has been so since the last 10 minutes. It was past 5.15 and I decided to move to yet another queue to buy my ticket asap.

This time I joined the queue at counter 5. Even this queue was moving quite fast but as soon as I was the 2nd person (again!!) in the queue, the guy at the counter got up and just walked away - without saying a word. My eyes followed the man to the sides of the rectangular room until I could see no more. He was probably talking to someone in the other part of the room and drinking water. After 2 mins, he started walking towards his seat but just passed by. He went out of the office from the back door w/o even looking at the window (and the customers) he was supposed to attend. I started looking sideways, only to realize that the queues were no more short. There were just 2 queues now (at 4 and 5) and both had atleast 13-15 people compared to four 6-7 people long queues just 15 mins back. It was like, though the system had made provision for the passengers to get their tickets asap, it wasn't practically possible just because of the negligence of the employees towards their work.

I saw a woman with a 5 year old kid trying to get a ticket at counter 4; but to other's complain, refusing to stand in the line. On being asked, she said she can't stand in a line of 15 people with a kid that small. Obviously she was making excuses (and playing on emotions of others) to cut the line and get her work done easily but methods should be adopted so that people don't get a chance to exploit other's kindness. Methods, that are already there on paper but are hardly implemented.

After another 5-7 mins, the counter incharge came back and resumed his work as lazily as ever. Well, ignoring all the feelings I had against that guy (and against the Indian Railways) at that moment, I quickly bought my ticket and rushed towards the platform.

Staying in a foreign country, I've realized one thing: Its not the technical advancements and better quality goods that make a nation work smoothly; its the people - their behaviour and their attitude towards their fellowmen that paves the way for a developing country towards attaining its goals. Unless we start to believe in one another and exchange respect, India's path towards the First World seems to be indispensably difficult.

23 comments:

Anonymous said...

hmmmmm.....so i am the first one to read this and comment on it...i have faced the 'scenarios' described herein many many times in India...moveover this blog does more than relating two incidents about the 'negligence' of the employees-it gives a serious message to all of us who proudly call ourselves 'INDIANS' that its high time to wake up from the deep slumber we always seem to be enjoying and realize our duties as responsible and aware citizens

Quarter Past Seven said...

good post :)
It's the people who make the country. I had to exchange an item at a store, and I got sent to every floor and almost every counter of every floor of that store... right here in singapore.. Three guesses for the name of the store? :P

Anonymous said...

well written.....lamba tha par bhawnaon ki prastuti acchchi thi.......:)

Siddharth said...

@bart

??
Mustafa?

aur ye bhi koi comment tha?? i mean my first "serious" post and just a mere "good post"?? :(

Quarter Past Seven said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Quarter Past Seven said...

bingo!
and I knew you would say this.. I was just waiting.. mwahahahaha.. *nasty evil and whatever else you can imagine grin*

Nahi.. It's a very well written post.. keep it up! :)

I actually have quite strong opinion abt this..

We are always cursing people of our country, never accepting that we are one of them too.. we are the ones who has done this to the country. We are the ones who look for rubbish bins in singapore and throw away the same chocolate wrapper on the roads in india.. we are the ones who attend meetings and work for societies in singapore and we are also the ones who tell our groupmates to take a walk had the same society been in delhi..

We have a bad habit of putting the blame on others. We blame the system, we call it corrupt, without realizing that we are the ones who form the system. We have taken our democracy forgranted. We love to flaunt about our millions of rights, not caring about our responsibilites towards the country, more importantly, towards other people of our country.

How many of us get up from our seats on the mrt to give it to an elderly? and how many of us have done that in india? We go to Indian Embassy all saja dhaja over here in Singapore, how many of us actually bother to listen to the PMs speech on 15th August. It's time we realise that it is "us" who is reponsible, not just the "people" in the system.

The lady breaking the queue is as much to blame as the person sitting behind the counter.. I second you on that one!

oops..got carried away.. this could well have been a post on my link! lol

I watched this video yesterday..

http://youtube.com/watch?v=L46pziPTYH8

Siddharth said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Siddharth said...

Yes, you're definetly right about it. It's "we" who are to be blamed. And that's why I've written "Mera" Bharat Mahan. :)
Lemme try to make it clear what I am trying to do. Having stayed out of the country (and especially in a developed nation), I'm trying to look for what is lacking in our country. It's like looking at a problem from somewhere above - to have a clearer picture of the overall problem.
Its like looking towards the wrong (or incomplete)solution of a math problem, after having a look at the answer at the back of the book. I hope you got my point. And surely, I, myself have to work out the perfect solution - atleast for my part of the problem. Isn't it?

Quarter Past Seven said...

lol.. I wast personally attacking you! I said i second you :D
Its just the common sentiment of the people that disgusts me. WHat we are here, why cant we be at home? Actually, I have an answer to that as well.. Coz no one else is.. People laugh at me when I go and look for dustbins in India..

You know, I feel RDB really has had an impact on people. A lot of us are already doing our part..however small..but we need a few more RDBs to get it into the people.. We need a massive change..and no doubt the change has to start from within us.

Confused Soul said...

Woah! What do we have here? A heated debate!!

Bart has already said almost all that I wanted to..about how in Singapore, we would not dare spit on the road, throw even a bit of paper out of place, even try to bribe a police officer..etc..But in India, we would do all this aankh band karke!

[I've actually recieved a forward stating all this.. something like Dr. Abdul Kalam's letter to the nation or something.. I'm sure you must have read it too...]

We are the people to blame, no doubt, and we have to rectify it, no doubt.. only how that will happen, I don't know. I guess as long as there is illiteracy and poverty, there will be corruption, and as long as there is corruption [and loads of it] nothing can go right. In India you can work your way arond anything if you have the money to fill certain people's pockets.. I guess even the laws aren't very strict..

But all this is a really broad topic and one can argue for days on it.. but you've touched a certain aspect of it.. Well done! I especially liked these lines..

//This person would have been appointed here to lessen the burden of the Officers at Delhi. And he is sitting ideally in this busy office doing absolutely nothing – so much so – he tends to avoid every work that comes his way. I thought of the various facilities and privileges people are offered while (and after) working in a Government Office and about the amount of work they (don't) do.//

In one of your very first posts, I had said that you should blog about other things, not just lame jokes.. but then you didn't listen..ab aaya na oont pahad ke neeche :P Oh btw, I guess the officers in Delhi very over-efficient and they checked your transponder ka package too well, and decided to confiscate it..or to think from another perpective, maybe there were too lazy..and the transponder looked a bit suspicious.. that gave them enough reason to detain it.. who was going to take the trouble to actually check it and see if they were right or not? :P

Quarter Past Seven said...

Dear Confused Soul

I think you are actually confused :P I didn't quite get what your opinion is. On the one hand, you agreed with what I said, and then in the next line you blamed it all on our dear old poverty, illiteracy and hence corruption. I differ. My stand was not to blame the system. It is 'we' who form it. And I think we should stop calling our country poor and illiterate.

More so, we need to stop blaming each other. We need to respect our country much more than we do now.
And please send me the "Dr. Abdul Kalam's letter to the nation or something", if you still have it in your mailbox. I haven't read it yet, but I want to read it.

Siddharth said...

haha..I think the "heated debate" has shifted from b/w Bart n Siddharth to b/w Bart n Confused Soul.. n I'm already enjoyin it.. C'mon you 2..keep it going! :P

@Bart
I didn't actually get the "why can't we be at home" part...but I really think RDB has changed us a lot...never thought a movie could have inspired us so much..i wonder if Rakeysh Mehra expected the same from his movie..hehe!

@Confused Soul
I agree with u that "illiteracy" is one of the biggest problems facing our country; in other words, proper education for EVERYONE is the need of the hour. But inspite of that there are other things that need to be looked into to make our country "Saare Jahan Se Achha!". Don't you think that the custom officer and the railway guys were educated? Agreeing with all that you said, I'd say that this article was not about illiteracy, it was about what is missing in the so-called Educated Indians - a feeling of respect towards others and a commitment towards their duties. And how these small things constitute in defining the successful-ness of a country.

Quarter Past Seven said...

lol..its not much of a debate really.. just putting my two cents worth.
That sentence is a bit wrongly framed, it just means why can't we be the same in both countries.

Confused Soul said...

#Bart Simpson,

My stand is that it's the people to blame, or rather the attitude to the people that is the problem. And I think that the attitude of the people is like this because of certain reasons may be, one of which is corruption. What I mean to say here is this, you get to a high post by bribing someone, and you get a higher salary. But may be you aren't qualified enough [not in the railway counter case] or you are sure there will be no one to question how you work coz you have bought them already. So my stand is this: It is the people who are at fault, and that in turn is because we have made the system corrupt. So it is interlinked.
And how can we not call our country poor and illiterate? Just because we have a few hundred cities? The vast majority is still the villages..
And yes, we should stop blaming each other, only if we are doing so to rectify something in the system..

#Sid,
I know this post is not about illiteracy. I was going into a broader issue and that's why I stopped saying that one can argue about this for days.
In relation to this post, all corruption n whatever starts somewhere.. I was just saying that the root cause is poverty and illiteracy..It all starts at the lower level and carries on..
And for the educated people, by illiteracy I mean not having work ethics and the feeling of responsibility. What's the use of having a degree if you don't have values? India is known for it's strong value system.. so I don't know why all this is happening.. but again, this is deviating from this topic.. but all these topics are interconnected..when it comes to any issue in India, you can start at one point and connect it anywhere! Are we looking at the western countries and becoming greedy? [I remember when an MNC took over MTR in Bangalore, the workers went on strike and demanded the same pay as an MNC, which was much higher than what they were receiving. I don't know what connection this has with the post, just remembered it, so I mentioned it.]

Well, someday we should sit and discuss this and related topics..that'll be fun! :)

Confused Soul said...

#Sid and Bart,
Just remembered one more thing.. The politicians always target the farmers and people in rural areas when the elections are near.Their strategy:Make use of the poverty and the fact that most of the people there haven't been to a secondary school.They make certain promises to them, and throw a couple of colour TV's at them [and this is how they use the money we pay as tax] and viola! Victory is theirs! And there you had the first stage of corruption. And from there it carries on to the other officers and the work they (don't) do..So I guess, everything is just inter-connected!

Oh and did you guys realise? Out of the 14-15 comments so far, there are only 2 non-[sid,bart,cs] comments.. :P

Siddharth said...

yup!
all this is surely inter-connected...and we should really sit down to talk about all this one day... it'll be fun! :P
and if it isn't funny enough, we'll ask Shankar to join us in the arguement...then it'll surely be fun..hehe!
dunno why I mentioned his name...i think i've been missing him and his absent-mindedness... :)

Shashi said...

hey siddharth.. well written.. but u know that no country is perfect..
and it is a system... and system is bad ,!!!!! just a silly excuse..
as every system is made up of some joints , and as we are the part of that system, so we have some responsibilty 4 same... and as a part of this system also i feel some times that i m guilty in many cases.. so instead of blaming it, just try 2 improve it as u can.....

vaise article acha tha.. well written...

Siddharth said...

Yes sir...We surely are part of the system and of the problem too..
It was just an insight of what happens in the various offices in India...If u get some time (which I think u'll easily get this week) do go thru the other comments on this page...Its an interesting debate! :)

Shashi said...

hey thanks sir 4 advise.. debate was really good.. nothing new.. but wanna add 1 incident 2 that..

as 1 day i was ready 2 come back 2 home from my college in jalandhar. and there is a overbridge 2 cross the road , to enter in the bus stand.. i think so taht gov. had spend some money atlest 2 gain some thing.. but surprise 2 me... i was the only person on the over bridge, all other passengers crossing the road by braking the traffic rules, intrupting the heavy traffic.. and in the end blaming the traffic police and gov. 4 that heavy traffic.. what a pity!!!! if gov. does something then even people (part of the system) does't seems 2 have any interest 2 use it.. insteade of this again blaming thje gov. 4 nothing.. so its the people , means all of us.. so we need 2 correct ourself 1st.. ...

Siddharth said...

Thats true sir...even I've seen many instances where people tend to avoid the provisions provided by the government, even for their own safety.
People's never-ending attempt to avoid wearing a helmet or using the seat-belt - even when made compulsary for public's own safety - are clear examples of such situations.

Shashi said...

thats right yaar... it is a endless loop of these examples.. but still 1 thing that i can do is... to be honest with me.. and u know i continued that way by crossing that overbridge every time.. and after some tym atlest my fruends start 2 follow me on that.. so i was glad 4 that.. and also i feel that as an educated person we have some more reponsibilty then otheres.. so some 1 needs 2 lead the way.. so just start doing that.. and believe me .. other wioll follow.. but yes it will take some tym dear..

carisima said...

U have a wonderful descriptive ability! jus like da Geminis are supposed to have... :) keep practising here n il im sure i shall witness you turning into a prolific writer in the future! best wishes :) :)

Siddharth said...

Thanks a lot Megha!! :)