Reflection or Illusion?
Two long years of travelling between India and Singapore and where have I reached? I wonder why the feeling of patriotism and the sense of pride towards India took over me only after going to Singapore. I guess (also most-rightly said) we realize the actual worth of anything only after losing it. But have I really lost India? Or am I losing it in pieces?
There are times in Singapore when I come across Indian books, literature, culture and most influencingly the magnificent pictures of our innumerable national heritages. Several of my friends can act as witnesses to my hyper level of excitement during these moments. How I feel rejoiced if I can find something Indian on the streets, mention about India in SS modules or at the museum, about Subhas Chandra Bose's presence in Singapore even before independence, the president of Singapore being of an Indian origin and most importantly, Singapura - the name itself derived from Hindi. These things have always made me realize how much I love India and miss it during my time in Singapore.
But this time in India, a nascent feeling has surrounded me. I've started experiencing a sense of pride in being a part of Singapore - of this tiny state where I've spent merely 6.4% of my whole life (till date i.e.) Comes a news referring to what's new (or old) about Singapore and I find myself reading through the whole article as if trying to experience the comforts of my second home once again. All the more, I'll start talking about the different places I've been to and what's good (and rarely about what's bad) at certain places to whoever is sitting beside me.
It is turning out to be a total reciprocation of the feelings I have for India when in Singapore. When in India, I've always missed Singapore - the university, my friends, the climate, the easy transportation and the friendly and helpful nature of (most) people. But that doesn't mean that I've started looking down upon India. The rich culture of my country has always fascinated me and will continue to do so.
But I fear. I fear of being torn apart between these two nations. One, which gave me birth and helped me grow into what I am today and the second that is supporting me to build myself, a bright and reassuring future. Roughly speaking, I've been staying out of India for 2 years now but to be precise, I've just spent 494 days in Singapore. And I'm already having a feeling of being shared by the 2 countries. How can Singapore imprint an impression on me so deep in so less time that I've started looking at it the same way I look at India when overseas?
I wonder if it's a feeling of my acceptance of Singapore (and vice versa) or am I just being fascinated by a "developed" nation where there is absolutely nothing in the name of culture or natural beauty but artificially-lined trees, unnatural beaches and a working environment so alarmingly comfortable that it can easily make a jellyfish of a person. I am yet to discover what really is in my heart for this "City of Choices". Does it really takes India's place when I'm already here or is it just an illusioned reflection I'm looking at?
Monday, June 18, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
21 comments:
Awesome post :)
I was just thinking about this song today..
Na jaane kyun.. hota hai yeh zindagi ke saath.. Achanak ye mann.. kisi ke jaane ke baad, kare phir uski yaad, choti choti si baat..
Na jaane kyun..
I guess the same thing applies to places and the environment you live in..When in Singapore, you long for the little things at home that you miss here.. parents,the comforts of home, good food, your own vehicle, friends back home, chaat on the street, power cuts once ina while :P.. dogs on the street, sadak kinaare poty karte hue bache :P.. haha.. n so on and so forth..That's because we've grown up in India, in our very own country and spent all our life there..
But when in India, you miss Singapore coz Singapore is your present..you've gotten used to it..your uni,your friends, hostel..independence..that's your way of life..and you miss all the other kinds of comforts you have here..as you said..easy transportation, clean roads, a system free of loop-holes [most of the time], etc..May be because it's more developed than India [that doesn't mean we look down upon India], may be because you're proud to be studying here..may be because.. it's simply your second home..
Sometimes even I wish that I was in just one place..not shuttling between two countries.. but I've gotten used to it and I'm quite liking it, coz I get the best of both worlds now :)
And as far as your acceptance of Singapore goes, it's definitely not taking India's place..As I said before, I guess it's because Singapore is your present..and may be, it holds your future as well.. and if you don't accept the place you live in, you won't be happy..
The missing India in Singapore and Singapore when in India reminds me of this - In school, we always wished for vacations during term time..and come vacations, we would count days to the day school began..I guess, life's like that! :)
Well you are not the first one to acknowledge this fact. Life is like this only..u are torn between two nations as both of them have their share of importance for you..U miss India in singapore..ur family, culture, home cooked food, and everything that comes with the package..It has made you the way you are..While in India you miss singapore coz you have your freedom, your friends, cleanliness, easy administration, better organization and so on..There is nothing wrong with that..Infact i feel the same way about delhi and jaipur..(though in the same country and only some 400 km(roughly) apart)..Delhi is the developed city in India, the life here is very fast, it is where i have spent most of my life, my school , my friends all are here..but still i miss jaipur when i am i Delhi and vice virsa..Maybe becoz i miss my independence , the ability to take almost all of my decisions, friends, etc etc etc..Let me put it this way Delhi is the place where I grew up and it was only in Jaipur that i realized myself as an individual..Well this is jst the beginning..We have to learn to love the place where we stay .....Only then can we enjoy our work..ourselves whole heardtedly.... :D
@CS
yeah..
I was just trying to figure out if I miss Singapore as much as I miss India...I guess even if I do so, the feeling of apnapan can't be the same...
I guess I miss India coz I am an Indian and its my homeland. On the other hand, I have a sense of pride in being a student in a developed nation like Singapore where you find (as you said) loop-hole free systems :) I guess its just an attraction towards all the goodly things there. But this is just a guess.
Actually I can't figure out right now...hehe...nvm. :)
@Monica
hey...It isn't about "missing" Singapore when in India. Its about the feeling I get when I hear/read anything about Singapore.
When in Singapore, I don't actually miss the different features and comforts I have at home. I miss "India" as such. As a country..as my country. And these days, I've started feeling the same for Singapore also...Its not just about the easy life, independence n all those things...Its about this country which has eventually become my second home. I hope its getting clearer to you (as it is getting to me now :P)
Through this post, I'm just trying to identify if Singapore holds an equal place in my heart as India...
This deserves a pat on the back! And since it is exceptionally well written, even though my fingers are itching for it, I refuse to do any autopsy of this post :)
To tell you my view, seedhi si baat hai. Being in these two countries is like being in love and being infatuated at the same time. One is like the wife you just have to go back to, at the end of the day. The other is your long-legged secretary you can't help staring at and love to share lunch with. Your wife is the reason you want the clock to strike six in the evening and you secretary is the reason you look forward to 9 am. Both giving you a reason to look forward to life in their own ways ;) waddyasay?
Thanks a lot for saving me from the pains of defending my view point.. :P
I think you've given an excellent example of what's goin on in my life but I don't have much experience of both love n infactuation :P. May be thats why I'm feeling odd... :)
wah..kya baat hai!! U have actually started writing good posts... I haven't experienced the "Missing Singapore in India" yet but I guess its humane..
Anyways, just one correction... Singapura is derived from Malay, not hindi!!
Bahasa Malay, Bahasa Indonesia and Hindia have been derived from Sanskrit.... Thats why there is a lot of resemblance in the 3 languages....
@Shubhi
Thanks for the compliment Ma'am... :) sab CTW ki den hai.. :P
aur meri G.K. mein badhotri karne ke liye Dhanyawaad...No wonder you know so much about Indonesia (and Malaysia)... :P
Anyways, coz its indirectly derived from Sanskrit, it still makes me feel proud about it.. :)
Its been a long time visiting your blog.. and i actually did to check out some super lame jokes.. but boy am i surprised or wat!?!!
I guess u are just experiencing what ive for the past 7 years.. and the line that stands between India and Singapore will soon be thinner and more blur until it fades away.. when finally you will accept yourself being coherent with both countries... longing for one while in the other!
Kudos to the post!!
Hey Satya...thanks a lot!
The lame jokes will be back soon...but I've realized only recently that i have caliber to write abbout other things too.. :P
read about ur photo blog... will visit soon..Not much access to the Net these days... thats y...
hey...haha wow awesome awesome report!! english has gone up de roof (in a good sense)! nice to noe...hahaha.... =) guess who :P
kisne fail kiya quet mein? useless people... awesome post! brought out all feelings perfectly!
and yeah! arushi write on your own blog!! =P
and komal! wow! what can i say! wow! wow!
haha.. Shankar..thnaks for reading the whole thing and then actually commenting on it... :P
Pri darling..may be it's the difference, modules like EG and CTW have made that's showing up in these posts. I personally believe they've helped me a lot in raising my english standards... :P
n nice comments for Arushi n Komal... :)
Woaaah! Priyanka! :D three wows..in one sentence!! If you were in front of me now, you could have counted all my teeth.more than once, i am smiling so wide!
*wiping that chhotu tear of joy from my eyes* Thankyou :)
Surprisingly this is a thought I myself have pondered on. Staying in Singapore for the past 5 years, I’ve realized the importance of India and what it lacks. When I go back to India, similarly I can feel what we lack in Singapore. But there is such a fine line between this knowledge and ignorance that I’m unable to put my finger to it. Now I consider both these countries my land but which one is home I’ve no idea. When I’m in one county I yearn for the other.
Anyway Siddharth I congratulate you on having had enough words to put down a feeling in writing which I suppose many of us (who have been in Singapore for long) must have thought of at some point or the other. Awesome post!!
for your kind information, Singapura was derived from Tamil and not Hindi. Singa-Singam-Lion. I guess you need to research a bit before writing.Nevertheless, good attempt!
well, there have been people correcting me on this.. some say its from Malay.. which itself is derived from Sanskrit...
anyways, I aplogize for my mistake.. thanks for pointing out... :)
Came across your blog recently - I dont think there is anything left that hasnt been said by the others...but being an NRI and living my entire life abroad I can tell you that this is only a natural feeling...
I spent a total ot 2.5 yrs in India before moving abroad and since then have only gone back for summer/winter vacations spanning a few months...and yes I identify with each country i've lived in...even if it was in a country for 3-4 yrs when i was below 6 yrs...
I still look out for news articles on each country and recently I still support that country players in the Olympics!
I think its because each country, each nation helps add a little more to who we are today - each gives its own tweak to our personality today...each nation's culture adds a little more to the medly of the person we are today...and i guess this is what people mean when they talk about global citizens! :)
A well written post it is :)
Oh an don't fear being torn apart - that will never happen...each country you stay in will just add on to the layers of the person you are...it will be one more country to love, one more place to re-live memories about and one more time to miss in our lives... :)
Post a Comment